• A project of ASAPbio
    • About
    • Add listing
    • Glossary
    • Blog
    Explore
    Sign in or Register
    Explore

    Axios Review

    A brokerage between authors and journals

    • Share
    • Bookmark
    • Profile
    • Comments 0
    • prev
    • next
    • Website
    • Leave a comment
    • prev
    • next

    In a nutshell

    Axios Review exists to eliminate the huge inefficiency at the heart of scientific publishing: Authors cannot currently submit to a journal that wants their paper. The resulting search for a suitable journal wastes researcher time, inflates the cost of journals, and ultimately slows the progress of science.

    Axios applies the long-established brokerage model to scientific publishing. We conduct a rigorous editor-led peer review process and then find a journal that wants the paper. This approach is highly effective: 85% of Axios papers get accepted at the journal (compared to <30% for the current system). Half of the accepted Axios papers are not re-reviewed by the journal. Our papers are published with under 2 rounds of review (vs. 5 in the current system) without any loss of rigour.

    Goals and intentions

    The current process for publishing scientific research is highly inefficient:

    - Researchers need to publish their papers in high profile journals to win funding.

    - High profile journals receive many thousands of research papers every year.

    - 70 to 95% of these papers are rejected, the majority for poor fit or lack of novelty.

    - Researchers must then submit their papers to another journal.

    - Most papers are assessed again and again by different journals before being published.

    - This takes up researcher time, raises the cost of journals, and slows the progress of science.

    Project status

    • Completed

    Types of outputs

    • Preprints
    • Privately shared manuscripts

    Review process

    • Review requested by
      Authors
    • Reviewer selected by
      Editor, service, or community
    • Public interaction
      No
    • Author response
      Yes
    • Decision
      Binary decision, Other scale or rating

    Review policy

    • Review coverage
      Complete paper
    • Reviewer identity known to
      Editor or service
    • Competing interests
      Not included

    Review features

    • Manuscript hosting
      No
    • Notes

      Axios Review applies the long-established brokerage model to facilitate the interaction between authors and journals:

      - Scientists send us their papers and suggest target journals.

      - We use standard editor-led anonymous peer review to evaluate the research.

      - We offer the paper to the appropriate target journals.

      - The journals use our evaluation to decide whether they want the paper.

      - Once we have found an interested journal, authors revise their paper and send it in.

      - Journals either re-review the paper or accept it for publication immediately

      Scientists can thus submit to a journal that wants their paper, and journals receive papers they actually want.

    • Review of code or data
      No
    • Eligible reviewers/editors
      Axios staff recruited academic Editors, the Editors picked reviewers (with occasional help from Axios staff)
    • Tags or badges
      No
    • Criteria for inclusion

      Articles reviewed by Axios generally appeared in normal academic journals. Authors were asked to add a line thanking Axios Review for feedback to their acknowledgements

    • Cost
      250
    • Explanation of cost
      The fee covered i) editorial office & staff salaries, ii) overheads, and iii) promotional activities.

    Transparency

    • Double blind
    • Single blind

    Results

    • Number of scholarly outputs commented on
      100-1,000
    • Metrics
      We collected lots of peer review metrics.
    • Results summary

      We received 470 submissions, with almost 200 of those arriving in 2016. At the last time of checking (early 2017) 130 had been published in academic journals, mostly high profile journals in ecology and evolution.

      We consistently found that 85% of Axios papers were accepted at the interested journal (compared to under 30% for the current system). Half of the accepted Axios papers are not re-reviewed by the journal, greatly increasing the speed of the publishing process.

      Most Axios papers were published with fewer than 2 rounds of review, compared to over 5 in the current system. Excluding the time authors spend on revisions, we averaged 3 months between the paper arriving at Axios and being published in a journal.

  • No comments yet.
  • Add a comment

    Leave a Reply · Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Cart

      • Facebook
      • X
      • WhatsApp
      • Viber
      • Telegram
      • LinkedIn
      • Tumblr
      • Reddit
      • VKontakte
      • Mail
      • Copy link
      • Share via...
      • Threads
      • Bluesky